Buddhism and Empire III: the Dharma King

Among the most celebrated figures in Tibetan history are the “dharma kings” (chögyal in Tibetan) who supported Buddhism and helped it to take root in Tibet. And probably the most important of all the dharma kings is Tri Song Detsen. Prince Song Detsen was given the title Tri – meaning “throne” – when he came of age, and he wasted little time in curbing the anti-Buddhist movement that had taken root in recent years since the death of his father, the previous king.

Seeking Buddhist teachers, first from China, then from Nepal and India, he went about getting Tibet its first proper monastery. That monastery, Samyé, was built with the help of the Nepalese abbot Śāntarakṣīta and the tantric adept from modern Pakistan, Padmasambhava. The king also supervised the ordination of the first Tibetan monks, and a vast project for the translation of Buddhist scriptures into Tibetan.

That is the briefest of summaries of the traditional Tibetan view of Tri Song Detsen’s achievements. If we turn to the Dunhuang manuscripts, we find – for once – that they are much in agreement with that traditional view. Tri Song Detsen is celebrated in quite a few Dunhuang poems and prayers as a great Buddhist king. Most of these celebrations of the king have already been translated (see the References section below) but I recently came across one that seems to have been missed. And it’s really quite interesting indeed…

* * *

IOL Tib J 466 is a scroll with a long prayer of offerings to the buddhas, bodhisattvas, deities, dharma kings and patrons of Buddhism. First among the kings is, of course, Tri Song Detsen.

I make offering to the spiritual teachers of our own Tibet,
The great dharma kings, like the great king Tri Song Detsen,
He who has mastered the royal methods of fortune,
And rules the kingdom with the sword of the sky-gods,
The magically emanated lord Tri Song Detsen;
And to those teachers who have gone to nirvāṇa,
Including Dharmāśoka, Kaniṣkā, Śīla Atidāna and so on;
To all of these propagators of the teachings
I respectfully make the offering of homage.

I suspect that this prayer dates from not too long after the reign of Tri Song Detsen himself. Every aspect of the scroll – paper, ink, handwriting, and the arrangement of the text on the page – is similar to the sutras commissioned by the last Tibetan kings at the end of the Tibetan Empire in the 840s. So the scroll may have been written only a half-century after the end of Tri Song Detsen’s reign.

The prayer puts Tri Song Detsen right into the historical tradition of dharma kings. Dharmāśoka is of course the famous Aśoka, ruler of the great Mauryan Empire in the 3rd century BC, and patron of Buddhism. Some of the edicts that he had carved throughout his empire still survive, and confirm that he was, to some extent, a Buddhist king. He is said to have convened the third council of the Buddhist sangha to clear up some doctrinal issues. As for Kaniṣka, he was the ruler of the Kushan Empire, based in Gandhara in the 2nd century AD, and we have evidence from the coins made in his reign that he supported Buddhism (among other religions). He is also credited with organizing a Buddhist council for the compilation of a Sanskrit Buddhist canon.

Considering the importance of the councils that Aśoka and Kaniṣka are supposed to have convened, it’s not surprising that the debate between Indian and Chinese Buddhism organized by Tri Song Detsen is often considered to be another council – in the grand tradition of dharma kings.

Of the identity of the king called Śīla Atidāna I have no idea. The first part of his name means “moral conduct” and the second “supreme giving”. The extreme generosity of bodhisattvas in some Buddhist stories is sometimes called “supreme giving”. One of the most popular of these stories is that of Prince Vessantara, who gave away his wife and children to a cruel Brahman (perhaps we should translate atidāna as “extreme giving”). In the end of the story the family is reunited and Vessantara is crowned king. So it could be this king that is intended here. I welcome any alternative suggestions…

*  *  *

As well as associating Tri Song Detsen with this Indian tradition of dharma kings, the prayer highlights the divine and magical nature of Tibetan kingship. The king has “mastered the royal methods of fortune.” What I’ve translated here as “fortune” is the enigmatic word phywa. In later Tibet it refers to luck, fortune-telling and the like. During the time of Tibet’s imperial kings, it seems to have been the special possession of the kings, but it as a method rather than a personal quality.

In any case, there wasn’t much distinction between the kings and the gods. The prayer also says that Tri Song Detsen “rules the kingdom with the sword of the sky-gods.” What does this mean? The Tibetan kings were thought to be the descendents (literally!) of a race of gods who lived in the sky, and came down to earth to perform their kingly duty. Instead of dying, they ascended back to the sky – beamed up along a “sky-cord” made of light. Later generations, including Tri Song Detsen, were said to have lost the sky-cord connection. Nevertheless, they were still the children of the gods (lhasé). That sword is an interesting symbol of the king’s military power, something that is downplayed – if not totally ignored – by many later Buddhist historians. Did Tri Song Detsen really carry a sword said to be inherited from his divine ancestors?

So it seems to me that in this prayer Tri Song Detsen stands somewhere between the earlier vision of Tibetan kings as agents of the divine – with magical military power and special royal methods of prognostication – and ideal of the Buddhist king as a patron and practitioner of Buddhism above all else.

*  *  *

Tibetan text
IOL Tib J 466/3: 5r.9–12: bdag cag bod khams kyI dge ba’I bshes gnyen//rgyal po chen po khri srong lde brtsan lastsogs pa//chos kyI rgyal po chen po rnams la mchod pa//phyva’i rgyal thabs mnga’ brnyes shing//chab srId gnam gyI lde mtshon can//’phrul rje khrI srong lde brtsan dang//dar ma sho ka/ka ni skā/shI la a tI da ṇya lastsogs//ston pa mya ngan ‘das phyIn//bstan pa rgyas mdzad thams cad la//phyag ‘tshal bsnyen bkur mchod pa dbul//

1. Karmay, Samten. 1998. “King Dza / Tsa and Vajrayāna” in The Arrow and the Spindle: Studies in History, Myths, Rituals and Beliefs in Tibet. Kathmandu: Mandala Book Point.
2. Richardson, Hugh Edward. 1998. “The Dharma that fell from Heaven” in High Peaks, Pure Earth: Collected Writings on Tibetan History and Culture, Edited with an Introduction by Michael Aris. London: Serindia.

1. Tri Song Detsen: detail of 20th c. painting, sourced from Wikipedia.
2. Coin of Kanishka, (c) The British Museum.
3. Sky-cord (OK, a tornado).

See also:
Buddhism and Empire I: A Soldier’s Prayer
Buddhism and Empire II: Portrait of a Monk

5 thoughts on “Buddhism and Empire III: the Dharma King

  1. I wonder if shI la a tI da ṇya could be a corruption of Śīlāditya, the name of several historical kings and I think also one of the names of Harṣa, a great patron of Buddhism?

  2. Yes – I do believe you may be right. If we ignore the sandhi, the Tibetan transcription of Śīlāditya could certainly be shi la a tid tya, and that is required to get from there to shI la a tI da ṇya (which is written on our scroll) is for the scribe to have inserted an extra tseg (dot) after ti and garbled the tya (actually, now I look at it, it could just about be a tya rather than ṇya after all).

    Thank you!

  3. Hello Sam,

    Good find! I have one minor point to make at present on the translation of the interesting sentence phyva’i rgyal thabs mnga’ brnyes shing//chab srId gnam gyI lde mtshon can/

    While phywa is similar to g.yang as “fortune”, the phywa are also the ancestral gods from which the Tibetan kings descended. In the songs of the Old Tibetan Chronicle, it is clear that the role of the king is to instantiate on earth the ways of the phywa in heaven. Indeed, the unswerving agenda of the Old Tibetan Chronicle, as a royalist document, is to aggrandize the king’s role as a world-ordering principle. I think it is in this sense that one should approach the phrase phywa’i rgyal thabs.

    Here is a relevant passage from the song of Khri ‘Dus srong in the Chronicle where phywa is used in the above sense.

    The subject—does he subjugate the lord,
    Or does the lord subjugate the subject?
    Our enemies above know!

    The man—does he ride the horse,
    Or does the horse ride the man?
    Those who instantiate the order of the Pywa Gods know (pywa ‘I ni gtsug mkhan mkhyen)

    Do the crops cut the scythe,
    Or does the scythe cut the grass?
    The narrow [earth] below knows!

    From now up to the edge of heaven,
    The sun and moon see with their eyes,
    The blue heavens hear with their ears,
    The order of the Pywa [Gods] will not change (pywa ‘I ni gtsug myi ‘gyur ).
    The feathers will not fall from the arrow.

    In my opinion “those who instantiate the ways of the pywa” (phwa ‘I ni gtsug mkhan) are the Tibetan kings themselves.

  4. Hi Brandon,

    Nice to hear from somebody interested in Tri Song Detsen. According to my stats pages, this is just about the least popular article I’ve posted – which was a surprise to me. Apparently the glamour of the tsenpos has little resonance these days.

    Anyway, many thanks for the phyva reference. You must be right that the divine ancestors of the tsenpos are indicated here. I also recently read Samten Karmay’s article on PT1038, in which the phywa feature among the tsenpo’s forebears.

    By the way, I like your translation of the Chronicle!


  5. In theravada you have a vessantara cycle of stories which is once or twice a year recited in the temples from early morning till late at night. It consists of a number of Jataka stories and is considered to tell about the penultimate life of the buddha before he became the buddha. Masi, the part of the cycle wherein Vesantara gives away his children and wife is one considered a very moving story and a prime example of dana – givng and merit making. For a study on the cycle see http://www.khamkoo.com/uploads/9/0/0/4/9004485/the_tham_vessantara_jataka_-_a_critical_study_of_the_vj_and_its_influence_on_kengtung_buddhism_eastern_shan_state.pdf

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s